Why Your Creative Testing Strategy Needs a Complete Overhaul

Your Content Should Sell is a free a newsletter that gives you practicals about creating content for your brand. It’s a must-read among DTC marketers and business leaders.

Was this email forwarded to you? Subscribe here

I used to be obsessed with optimization.

Like most marketers, I'd take a decent ad and iterate on it endlessly. "Let's try a new hook. Let's swap this shot. Let's rearrange the value props." Before you know it, I'd have created 20+ versions of basically the same ad.

But over the past year, my approach to creative testing has fundamentally changed.

Now I focus far less on optimizations and far more on generating completely new ideas. And the results speak for themselves.

Why endless iterations are killing your performance

Here's the harsh reality most creative agencies won't tell you:

Creating 20 versions of essentially the same ad is not "high volume creative production." It's a waste of resources.

Think about how the Meta algorithm actually works.

It's constantly searching for new buyers for your product. But when you're putting out 20 variations of what is essentially the same ad, you're not giving the algorithm anything truly new to work with.

Sure, you might see minor performance improvements between hook version #1 and hook version #3, but ask yourself:

• How much time did that take?

• Could that time have been better spent developing entirely new angles?

• Is Meta even seeing these as truly different ads?

The new framework that's winning in 2025

Here's what's actually driving results for our clients now:

1. Focus on big swings, not tiny tweaks

• Aim for 2-3 completely new creative concepts each month. This concept is not just a new creator video. I am talking BIG SWING.

• Limit iterations to 2-3 versions per concept (not 7+)

• Prioritize diversity in messaging and visuals over micro-optimizations

2. Spend your creative energy wisely

• Dedicate 70% of resources to developing new ideas

• Use the remaining 30% for strategic optimizations

• Never get caught in a cycle where you've spent a month on tweaks with no new concepts

3. Consider what the algorithm actually "sees"

• Meta likely views your slight hook variations as essentially the same ad

• Fresh concepts with different visuals and communication styles stand out

• The algorithm favors genuinely new creative over minor iterations

The counterintuitive truth

Yes, there are examples where the 5th iteration outperformed all previous versions. I've seen it happen myself.

When I analyze what has consistently driven the most success for our clients, it's always been a steady pipeline of fresh, new creative concepts, not endless optimization of existing ones.

The brands seeing the biggest wins aren't just iterating – they're innovating.

The hidden benefit beyond performance

When you focus on net-new concepts rather than endless tweaks, something magical happens: you discover entirely new ways to communicate your product's value.

This diversification isn't just good for immediate performance- it builds long-term brand strength and helps you reach audience segments you might have been missing.

Your creative testing reset

If you want to improve your creative testing approach:

1. Audit your current process: How much time are you spending on iterations vs. new concepts?

2. Establish a sustainable cadence for developing genuinely new creative ideas

3. Set a hard limit on iterations (I recommend no more than 3 per concept)

4. Reserve at least 70% of your creative resources for fresh approaches

Remember, in today's algorithmic environment, volume without diversity is just noise.

I hope this was helpful. Let me know if you want me to address anything in the future for you. Just reply and I can write about it.

Make sure to check out the podcast.

Until then, keep creating!

Matthew Gattozzi

Get a free assessment with Goodo Studios

My team and I create hassle-free creatives for consumer brands. If you are thinking about getting content, let’s set up a chat.

Content you should watch

We are dropping Youtube videos every few weeks, this was a fun one to dive into predictions of advertising. Let me know if you agree or disagree.

Did you know we had a podcast called In the Cutting Room. Episodes drop every Tuesday. Make sure to listen to it on Apple, Spotify, or Youtube.

Newsletters to Check Out